| Name | Year | School |
| Eva Zaragoza | 2019-21 | Embry-Riddle University |
| Nuria Castillo | 2019-21 | Ave Maria University |
| Lotte van Malsen | 2018-20 | Mount Mercy |
| Carla Callado | 2018-20 | Florida National University |
| Eva Carballo | 2018-20 | Converse College |
| Anna Jaumandreu | 2017-19 | Simpson University (CA) |
| Loralei Siliga | 2016-18 | Mid America Christian University |
| Claudia Morente | 2016-18 | Upper Iowa University |
| Alyssa Roth | 2016-18 | Hastings College |
| Barbra Araoz | 2015-17 | Missouri Valley College |
| JeAnn Hiraldo | 2014-16 | William Penn University |
| Jasmin Howe | 2013-15 | Northwest Missouri State University |
| Ilsie Calles | 2013-15 | Lindenwood University |
| Jamerka Martin | 2013-15 | Algoma University |
| Ashley Salgado | 2012-14 | Converce College |
| Mackenzie Gott | 2012-14 | Waldorf College |
| Rusty Henio | 2012-14 | Iowa Wesleyan College |